- SiteHome
- SectionNews & Thought Leadership
- ArticleTrenchless vs. Open-Cut Pipe Installation in Colora…

Every buried pipe has to get into the ground somehow. For most of the last century, that meant one thing: dig a trench, lay the pipe, fill the trench, rebuild what was on top. Trenchless technology offers another route. At Solid Earth, we have built water and sanitary sewer systems in Colorado since our first municipal water and sanitary contract in 2002. Owners planning that kind of work now face a real choice between methods. This article explains the options, what the evidence shows, and where it stops.
Two ways to put a pipe in the ground
Open-cut means excavating a continuous trench along the full pipe route. Trenchless means installing or renewing a pipe through small access pits at each end, with little or no digging in between.
Think of running a cable under a carpet. You can pull up the whole carpet, lay the cable and put the carpet back. Or you can lift one corner, push the cable through and lift the far corner to grab it. Trenchless is the second approach. The carpet is the road, sidewalk, lawn or creek above the pipe.
The precise version: trenchless work replaces surface excavation with underground drilling, pulling or lining. The pipe still gets placed or renewed. Most of the surface stays undisturbed.

The three main trenchless methods
Directional boring and HDD
Horizontal directional drilling (HDD) uses a steerable drill to bore a curved path underground, then pulls the new pipe back through the hole. It is a minimal-impact method with significant environmental advantages over traditional cut-and-cover installation.
The two names describe scale. “Directional boring” usually means small rigs, small-diameter bores and crossings measured in hundreds of feet. “HDD” usually means large rigs, large-diameter bores and crossings measured in thousands of feet.
Pipe bursting
Pipe bursting replaces an old pipe along its existing path. A cone-shaped bursting head is pulled through the old pipe. It breaks the pipe apart, pushes the fragments into the surrounding soil, and drags a new pipe in behind it. The old pipe becomes the guide for the new one.

Cured-in-place pipe (CIPP)
CIPP renews a pipe from the inside. A flexible liner soaked in resin is inserted into the existing pipe, pressed against its walls and hardened. The result is a new pipe inside the old one. It is common in sanitary sewers.
Colorado has already tested these methods
Colorado utilities have used trenchless work on high-stakes lines. Colorado Springs Utilities spent 15 years dealing with a failing 2,500-foot, 24-inch steel water transmission main under Galley Road, one of the city’s busiest streets. Global Underground Corporation, a Colorado Springs trenchless contractor, proposed replacing it by pipe bursting. Trenching that corridor would have meant years of traffic impact on a major road.
Smaller utilities have used it as a planned program, not a one-off fix. Starting in April 2010, Consolidated Mutual Water Company ran a pipe bursting program to replace about 25,000 linear feet of aging water mains.
A Colorado contractor’s guide lists where HDD tends to fit: road crossings, driveways, sidewalks, landscaped areas, crowded utility corridors, and anywhere restoration costs and public impact matter.

What the cost evidence shows
Several studies compare trenchless and open-cut costs directly.
- A study in the ASCE Library found that pipe bursting cost much less than open-cut for renewing underground infrastructure.
- A sanitary sewer study found CIPP cost 57%, 63% and 18% less than open-cut for small, medium and large pipes.
- The same study found that site restoration made up about 70% of total open-cut project cost.
- A 2025 systematic review found that open-cut disturbs 53 times more physical material than trenchless methods, and trenchless reduces traffic disruption costs.
The restoration figure explains most of the gap. Digging the trench is not the expensive part. Rebuilding the pavement, curb, sidewalk and landscaping on top is.
Where the evidence stops
These studies do not prove trenchless is always cheaper. Note the spread in the CIPP results: 63% savings for medium pipe, only 18% for large pipe. Savings depend on pipe size, depth, soil and what sits on the surface. A study of one region’s projects may not match conditions in Pueblo or the Front Range foothills.

Open-cut still has clear uses. When a route runs through open ground with little to restore, the main trenchless advantage shrinks. Gravity sewers need a precise, constant slope, and an open trench lets crews check grade directly. New lines with many service connections, structures like manholes and vaults, or difficult rock can also favor digging. Owners should treat trenchless as one option to price, not a default.
Colorado rules apply either way
Some requirements do not change with the method. Boring blind into a gas line is as dangerous as hitting one with a bucket.
- Locates: Colorado law requires excavators to request underground utility locations from Colorado 811 at least two working days before excavation or demolition starts, not counting the day of notice.
- Locatable new lines: Under Senate Bill 18-167, all new underground facilities installed on or after January 1, 2020, must be electronically locatable when installed. “Electronically locatable” means detectable from the surface with locating equipment. Non-metallic pipe, such as plastic, typically needs a tracer wire or similar aid to meet this.
How to decide: a practical sequence
- Define the job. Is it a new line or renewal of an existing one? Renewal opens up pipe bursting and CIPP. New lines point toward HDD or open-cut.
- Map the surface. List what sits above the route: roads, driveways, sidewalks, landscaping, waterways. More to restore favors trenchless.
- Map the subsurface. Request locates and review existing records. Crowded corridors favor methods that avoid a wide trench.
- Check grade needs. Gravity sewers with tight slope tolerances need careful method review.
- Price restoration honestly. Include pavement, traffic control and business disruption in the open-cut estimate. That is where most of the cost lives.
- Compare full costs. Weigh both methods on total project cost, not excavation cost alone.
Trenchless technology is now a proven tool in Colorado utility work. It wins where the surface is valuable and restoration is costly. Open-cut wins where the ground is open, the grade is critical or the job needs many connections. The right answer comes from the site, not the trend.
Have a project in mind? Start the conversation with Solid Earth.
Images are presented for illustration purposes only.We use real photographs when we need to show what was happening at a real event.











